My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

by Exactly Right Media – the original true crime comedy network
159,928
All Genres #24, True Crime #12

My Favorite Murder is a true crime comedy podcast hosted by Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark. Each week, Karen and Georgia share compelling true crimes and hometown stories from friends and listeners. Since MFM launched in January of 2016, Karen and Georgia have shared their lifelong interest in true crime and have covered stories of infamous serial killers like the Night Stalker, mysterious cold cases, captivating cults, incredible survivor stories and important events from history like the Tulsa race massacre of 1921.  My Favorite Murder is part of the Exactly Right podcast network that provides a platform for bold, creative voices to bring to life provocative, entertaining and relatable stories for audiences everywhere. The Exactly Right roster of podcasts covers a variety of topics including historic true crime, comedic interviews and news, science, pop culture and more. Podcasts on the network include Buried Bones with Kate Winkler Dawson and Paul Holes, That's Messed Up: An SVU Podcast, This Podcast Will Kill You, Bananas and more. 

More
Recent Episodes
Episodes loading...
Recent Reviews
  • Heyyoteach19
    Love them
    Listener since 2017. They’re the best. I don’t usually fill out ratings but we’ve gotta balance out the MAGA evangelicals.
  • Army wife 05
    Done!
    Saying to go vote is where it should end. Saying that we will be living in a dictatorship if we vote one way is horrible and is a great example of dividing people. We all have a right to speak freely, vote the way we want and not be judged. Sorry I can’t listen to a podcast anymore that wants to throw out words without any merit.
  • Imadeevah
    Meh
    Georgia’s nasal voice drives me absolutely nuts
  • Bkelly1107
    One of the greats
    So perfect for many reasons, I’ve listened for 4 years now and enjoy still playing old episodes when in need. Thanks so much you two + all the team members who make it happen.
  • ShaunieKaukanie
    Staying sexy
    Loving these two for years and years! Their story telling and support of mental health will rope you in and keep you going! My Favorite Podcast! SSDGM!
  • Rebekahcheyenne
    Lost a new listener
    I just started listening and really liked the show!!! Until episode 10 around minute 42 where they made it very clear they didn’t want trump supporters listening to them✌🏼 Have your opinions but why bring that into the podcast and blatantly say you don’t want us to listen to you? Ridiculous
  • Joyamanda:)
    Love!
    This show got me started on podcasts. I had a friend at a party refuse to let me walk away till I downloaded the podcast app and find this show. Now years later this is still my podcast I go to find first for episodes. I love these girls and simply can't get enough of them!
  • Corie Michele Cole
    :)
    Love them sm
  • Cass of Kensington
    Funny and honest!
    My favorite parts are drunk Karen (when Karen impersonates herself when she was an alcoholic), the honest stories about their youth and foibles, and the minisodes. And their right-on politics!! And MFM animated on YouTube is hilarious!
  • E. Sibley
    Comfort Podcast Til I Die
    Been with these ladies since 2017 so I can’t say I’m a day 1 Murderino, but I’m definitely up there. It’s not just way they beautifully merge their excellent humor with horrific and devastating stories but the way they do so without blurring the lines and whilst telling stories with respect for the victims. I’ve been through all my major milestones with them and I feel like they’ve gotten me all through it. I know if I ever met these ladies they’d embrace me with the same love I have for them.
  • LIGirlinWestchester
    Amazing
    I love this show. They are so funny and relatable. I listen in the car, while cooking, on a walk. Love this show!
  • Nish716
    Love ❤️
    It’s like being with hilarious friends enjoying their banter and getting my true crime fix. Even my husband chuckles when listening along on drives where I decided to play a podcast.
  • Hauling Tushy
    These two lovely humans…
    These voices have been there… through the terror of 2016 to 2020, the pandemic, seven family members passing away, a move across country, dealing with two parents with dementia, and a elderly parent-in-law, with some issues, and all the joyful things too. When I’m alone in the car or out for a walk and hear your voices I feel seen, I laugh, I appreciate how they always demonstrate accountability when they get stuff not quite right and live their values by talking about reproductive rights, oppression, and donating money to follow those values. I mean, thank you Karen and Georgia!
  • HiBigA
    Day 1 Listener
    Been loyal to these ladies since 2016 and they’ve been 5 stars since the start. They feel like the best friends I’ve never met. Love them forever!
  • andabenjamin
    You’ve done it again!
    That was excellent. Thank you! —-Ben
  • MrBoysMom
    Rewind Wednesdays, THE BEST!
    I can’t get enough of this podcast! I was hooked the moment I heard them using the f-word four years ago and felt right at home:). And now that they are doing Rewind Wednesdays, I’m a Day One listener! The BEST podcast!
  • KLJones1989
    MyFavoritePodcast
    Feels like you’re just listening to two friends talk about interesting case, in the best way. Have loved it since 2018!
  • callherdubdaddy
    my favorite podcast
    been listening for years, it’s amazing
  • Carlene Camera
    ❤️❤️
    I absolutely adore this podcast! My favorite quote through the years is you’re in a cult, call your dad! And after listening to a recent rewind episode where it debuted, I immediately went to the store and found the T-shirt! Thanks for all you do.
  • Hooooooooorayyyy
    I love them !!
    My favorite!! I can listen all day everyday !
  • Dianaf911
    Always worth lietening
    Love these ladies.
  • Kmmm74
    Love the Rewind episodes
    The rewind episodes are great! It’s a good way for me to listen to the episodes again (for the third time). I mean, I don’t have a problem when it’s technically new again…right? Right. Love Karen and Georgia!
  • KMB08222
    Triflers need not listen
    Karen and Georgia are the soundtrack to my life. Don’t think I could have gotten through the past 5 years that I’ve been listening to MFM without them.
  • NotNoodleN
    Comfort Podcast
    I’ve been listening to MFM since nearly the beginning. I find it so comforting to hear Karen and Georgia’s voices each week. I love listening to their stories each week and keeping up with their friendship.
  • jkjsmom
    Five stars forever
    My favorite podcast. I love both of these ladies so very much. I found them about 2 years ago. I started from the beginning and caught up quickly. I am hooked.
  • KYGreenCardBride
    True crime fun
    Love this! True crime with levity
  • MarathonRN
    Listening since 2019 and still love it!
    How have I been listening to this since 2019 and have not rate and reviewed yet?!?? Love listening to these ladies!
  • Patchoulidrop
    Let them vacay! 😆
    Who is making these women feel bad about taking time off?! Nobody? Oh, ok 😆😆🤣
  • Jewlsterry
    My Favorite Podcast
    This podcast is like therapy for me! Karen and Georgia feel like friends that I catch up with every week.
  • ENM5617
    It’s the banter for me
    The banter between Karen and Georgia is unmatched. On top of that they’re inspiring, witty, and advocates for mental health. The podcast has changed as they’ve grown and found success much as you would expect, but those points remain true. They continue to learn and grow and are excellent story tellers. I look forward to listening every week.
  • Jc-Ir
    Amazing show
    I am an old punker from the bay area so I love Georgias references in music and culture when they come up here and there. That’s definitely fun for me but of course the material in the stories you both present are amazing compelling interesting. We certainly have a dark side of humanity. We have to deal with here. But never forget the body in the bog. Right? Brutal. Hey, listen I really love these rewinds. I’ve listened to you guys on and off for a long time, but it almost makes me just wanna reboot the whole series so I’ll just keep listening to these. Rock on!
  • Ftaco12
    Only Podcast To Return To Again & Again
    I stumbled onto My Favorite Murder many years ago when I asked a friend about her “SSDGM” bumper sticker. I read the book and found the MFM podcast. I am fascinated by true crime. I appreciate Georgia and Karen’s realness, feminism, senses of humor, and advocacy. I try to get into other podcasts, but this is the one I always come back to.
  • Kj2012!!
    Rewind Episodes
    Hey gals. The rewinds are great. Except when you interrupt the story a million times to add more commentary.
  • Cat A 24
    Rewind episodes
    Loving the rewind episodes. Karen sounds excited about doing the podcast back then.
  • ZennyDrecona
    Icons
    This is THE show that changed the true crime podcast landscape. These woman tell the worst stories in the best way. If you haven’t listened yet, you should!
  • Albertfishproductions
    My go to
    Love love love them. Best stories! They’re in my ear at all times!!
  • needswine
    The best!
    This podcast cured my plantar fasciitis!
  • Allusion of my mind
    The Best (updated
    Truly unmatched. One of the only two podcasts I can listen to. ^that was my first rating. Here is an update: Anyone else feel like the rereleased podcasts are making you realize K&G have sold out? The show is so commercialized now. They don’t even chat they just get straight to advertising their own stuff right after a hella long segment of ads. It’s not as funny anymore and I miss what the show used to be. There’s only an actual true crime story maybe once every three episodes? Idk maybe this is just me.
  • Thai J
    Bias Politics
    This is a extremely biased left wing political podcast that used to be a true crime podcast. They are very condescending and dabble in as much fake news as anything that comes from the other side. I always tolerated it but it just wears on you over time. If you are on the right or in the middle then I doubt you will like this podcast. After many years of following, I am out.
  • Jinxy718
    Love Karen and Georgia!
    I’ve been listening since the beginning. It’s like chatting with long time friends. Karen and I are about the same age and I love the gen x references. She turned me onto Korean skincare too! Thanks!
  • Tessmeaow
    My besties
    They are with me through everything and I would die without them
  • Anonymous729492
    13 murdereno
    Hey! I’m a day 1 listener and I started when I was 13 years old! Don’t worry I’m doing great! ;) -A
  • dmurphy83
    5 stars
    This podcast cured my bursitis.
  • Meredear
    My cool aunts
    Been listening since covid and never stopped. Just my comfort podcast by this point. And if you get offended by their “liberal bull****”, perhaps look inward. All I have to say! Love ya!
  • AA3019
    All time favorite!
    Karen and Georgia have an intuitive flow that can’t be taught. They’re always funny, pick interesting stories, and I leave every episode feeling like my mental hunger has been fed with a nutritious meal, not junk snacks like insta scrolling. LOVE MFM!
  • Hannah Danie
    Still get excited for a new episode!
    These ladies have been in my ears and heart for many years. I look forward to Thursday and LOVE the new Rewind Episodes. My biggest request: LIVE SHOWS! Can’t wait to see you ladies in person. Also, the recorded live episodes are so endearing to me!
  • meggo_cheese
    Love this show
    Love! Such a good show
  • 658374
    Great show
    This was the first True crime show I listened to and definitely set the bar. Come for the stories, stay for the banter.
  • dudegoldblum
    Came for true crime, stayed for the politics ✌️
    If you can’t see how true crime is completely intertwined with politics, I would implore you to look inward. The cases they talk about are victims of the perpetrator, and often victims of the systems at large as well. Why are certain groups more often victims in these stories? Because our society and systems and laws are set up to value the white, rich, cis, men over anyone else. The injustices are inherently political. It makes me happy that MFM calls out these injustices and putting their money towards organizations who help fight inequality. Bringing awareness and support to these topics benefit us all. I love listening to Georgia and Karen talk, as it feels like I’m getting to sit at the adults table with my cool aunts. Thank you for being my ear buds throughout the years.
  • alexaw.
    My Favorite Podcast
    Love this show!
Similar Podcasts
Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork on this page are property of the podcast owner, and not endorsed by UP.audio.