Daniel is a fine host but Josh is a douche who swears way too much/unnecessarily. They talk about women like misogynistic 6th graders and their recaps of episodes are surface level and not well-researched. Do better.

Simply an ernest re-hash of highlights with some tv-gossip tossed in. Neither presenter seems to have any sort of deeper knowledge of the period, characters or anything actually to add to the enjoyment of the show.

one of these guys is alright but the other has no is a what is he talking about. they frequently get facts wrong that could easily have been learned with a little research. they also talk about women in a gross way, at one point referring to a man sexually assaulting a woman as “going to pound town”

Really enjoy the podcast, but hate when you do the elimination winners/losers or pick obscure ones. Just say who the obvious winners and losers were!

Thanks for doing the pods guys - just finished 6 on Netflix and can’t wait to listen to all these shows I’ve had to just delete as they popped over the last few months!

You guys are pretty, pretty, pretty good. Thanks for getting vaccinated. Still annoyed that you can’t pronounce Aberama correctly.

I admittedly got into the show very late in the game but seriously now that I am in, I am (fookin) LOVING it and this podcast is the best accompaniment! The show goes really fast and the accents are a little tricky to navigate on a first watch - I am anti watching it with subtitles bc I think it detracts from my Shelby viewing/ experience so I was relying on episode recaps. The episode recaps weren’t doing it for me so I found your podcast. Love Josh and Daniel!!! I really like the spoiler free format, I like the fact you can stay on for Grace’s Secret (I haven’t bc I am only through Season 4 episode 5)! The winners and losers is my favorite thing you guys do even though I totally disagree with you sometimes on the losers but hey that’s ok. I even like the accents you guys do, I listen at work and it makes me giggle. Everyone who loves this show needs to listen to this podcast - I have recommended it to everyone! Can’t wait to finish the show and get caught up on the podcasts to be ready for Season Six.

I am bouncing around listening but as recently as season 4 they are still doing accents which is grating. Your true voices are really nice, leave accents for privately quoting while doing dishes. Besides that truly enjoying <3

Daniel is great, but Josh is aggressive for no reason. Also, their views about the women in the show is kind gross “boys club”y.

I've watched the show already but it's good to hear different perspectives and focus on some details i may have missed when first watching it.

I like the main host but the co host literally never knows what he is talking about as he butchers accents and gets literally every fact about the series wrong !

Just found this after my first watch through of Peaky Blinders. Love hearing the deep dives and thinking of the broader themes!

This Podcast really hit it out of the Ballpark! Wow! Just loved it! Great work!!

This is a wonderful review of the Show

Love the podcast! DANIEL GILLMAN IS EXCELLENT!!

Daniel and Josh offer super intriguing perspectives on this awesome show. It’s extremely entertaining and I highly recommend listening!

WHERE HAVE YOU BEEN ALL MY LIFE (As long as I’ve watched Peaky...)

Love listening to this podcast full of fun facts and great voices. Keep it coming. Jacqueline FG

This podcast really goes in-depth on each episode helping you understand it even more and find things you missed while watching the first time. They also have special guest appearances that are awesome!

Can’t believe these two random American fans started a Peaky pod and got actual actors to come on! So cool

Been looking for a good podcast to listen to based off some of my favorite shows. Stoked to have found you guys!

Where are the rest of the episodes? I want the early ones. Please upload them?

Josh and Daniel are awesome. Covid quarantine made me really get into some shows I have been putting off and Peaky Blinders is one of the top 3-5 shows I have ever watched. It is surprisingly hard to find a Peaky podcast so I stumbled upon this one and these guys put out great content and are obviously big fans of the show. Hopefully we get a season 6 soon and can get back to Birmingham with Tommy Fookin SHELBY!!

These two claim to be fans of the show and claim to have watched multiple times but they REPEATEDLY get names, events and details totally wrong. For instance, in the season 4 finale recap they had a problem with why Angel Changretta wasn’t in the episode. John and Arthur had killed him in his hospital bed after Grace was shot as revenge. They pay zero attention to detail and frankly, just aren’t very smart. Don’t waste your time with these two.

As an American, I can say that I do not know a lot about English and Irish history, but if I were to start a podcast that involves it, I would at least do minimal research to try and understand. Couldn’t even get through the first episode.

My husband and I are late to this series. We are on Season 3 after only a few days of watching. Now we are obsessed and try to speak in accents - of course. Found yall yesterday and loving the pod. Yall are fantastic

So I’m going to disagree with you that this song isn’t over played, its definitely overplayed! it’s a good song, But I’ve been cringing throughout the series having to listen to this. I did like the use of other artists singing us in with the song. I’d say if the creator and director think it’s time to go. Then I’d heed what they say.

Been looking for something like this! I mean Arthur freakin Shelby posted that he listens to this

Love the podcast

I’m a big fan of the show and was excited to find this podcast. But just a few episodes in I am truly disappointed in the hosts lack of a female perspective. Quite a few times I hear the ladies described as “smoking hot” “crazy” “so annoying.” This oversimplified and dismissive point of view is crap. The women on this show are strong, resilient, and gritty. They are interesting and diverse and shouldn’t be reduced to a comment or two. While the male roles are dynamic and full of action and violence, the females on the show are more than relevant and deserve more thought. The writer of Peaky gave us 1920’s women in powerful roles like-law enforcement, union leaders, business partners, and family matriarch. Be more like Steven. ✌️

This podcast is a perfect accompaniment when watching The Peaky Blinders. Both the tone and format of the podcast are completely spot-on. Daniel & Josh are both funny, listenable and have just enough uncouth for the show. Don’t miss it.

Actually amazing. Everyone should listen to this podcast

It’s an ok podcast I like it however the accents makes me not even want to listen. It was cute at first but now it’s truly getting old

Listened to first and second episodes. They don’t know anything, and didn’t bother to find out anything. Not even how to pronounce headliner Cillian Murphys name. Not even Rudolph Valentino. If you’re young, you should know how to work Google. Just listening to BBC (Obsessed or other) would have given pronunciations -most of which are actually in the episode!!

These guys do a great job running over the episodes in detail, very similar to sports commentary, which adds a comedic side to this podcast for me, personally. However, there are some things lacking in this podcast. While they are both big fans of the show there is a lack of cultural knowledge on both their parts, which would be fine and all except this is regarding very basic important details. Also, while they label their episodes as ‘spoiler free’ what they mean to say is their episodes are ‘spoiler free’ with regards to the following episodes after the one they’re commentating on.

Hey guys, liked your S5 E3 review until you try to explain socialism, fascism, and communism and get it so blatantly wrong. Next time you should research your subject in advance or just don’t discuss it at all.

I’ve listened to a few episodes of this podcast and it is likable. The guys seem kind of young and therefore can’t really grasp some of the nuisances of the characters but they’re capable podcasters. It’s a good podcast for a general outline of the show. I’m going to keep looking for a more in-depth podcast. Someone that does some research on the characters and talks about all the real people who are being portrayed. And, that is something the guys continually point out. This is all off the cuff and not really researched or thought out.

Holy fook, I love these guys and this podcast. I’ve been dying to find a Peaky Blinders podcast and this is the only one that covers every single episode. Perfect for a long drive, and Josh’s impersonations are hysterical. 5/5 stars!

I was late to Peaky Blinders and this show had been invaluable in keeping everything straight. The hosts are knowledgeable and their love of the show comes through in every episode.

This is everything I've been wanting out of a Peaky Blinders podcast for years and it's finally arrived. Daniel and Josh cover each episode thoroughly and efficiently. I appreciate their affection for my favorite tv series of all time, they just get it. They are witty, funny and smart. I highly recommend it!

Love the pod cast.

Daniel and Josh provide great insights and a witty analysis of this amazing show. Love the humor and description of the action. Bloody well done on the English accents too!