100% Love the presentation these two cover the subjects !!!

My slow commute became much better once i discovered this show. So many true crime podcasts leave you wondering who did it. I love that we get a complete case with resolution each week. And it’s based on facts rather than rampant speculation.

As a long time true crime podcast fan, I can easily say that this is the very best. Excellent research and presentation, and hosts who are coming from a lifetime of knowledge and experience. What more than one ask?

This has become my favorite murder podcast! I started on episode 1. And have been on a binge dive for over a month now! Can’t wait to get to the most recent stories!! Thank you for what you guys are doing!!

Love the storytelling on these always-compelling cases! I’ve been an Audiochuck listener for years, and I just have to say that Anatomy of Murder has become my favorite! I love the breakdown of the investigation and insights. Love the empathy from all angles!

The female host is so annoying when she says her “S” sounds. She whistles and it drives me nuts.

They are well researched. Their chosen professions adds to the show because they give listeners insight as to what maybe going through investigators minds as they investigate the cases being presented.

My go-to, drive by myself listen. I find myself gasping at some of the evidence and cases.

Six ads in 15 minutes is too much.

Well-researched, well-presented, consistently informative!

The grammar, oy.

The storytelling, analysis, production quality and editing, the sensitivity, professionalism and voices of the hosts make this my favorite podcast in the genre… and that’s saying a lot.

The hosts are excellent at what they do and the stories are well laid out and organized. I only have one small complaint. When I click the link to see the cases it’s sends me to the home page and I have to scroll for it

I love AOM, I’m always waiting for Tuesday’s to hear the new episode.

Well researched, both investigative and prosecutorial perspectives are expressed as well as details of case are given. Note: see “had went” vs “had gone” Scott!

Interesting content but the amount of commercials you guys have beats out major studios. You have a commercial break ruffly every 5 minutes. Commercial time rivals content time. It makes it too hard to get into the content. I encourage people to do some research into Anna-Sigga. Lots of misconduct, including concealing evidence.

I love this show. Both hosts are very professional and speaks clearly and concise.

I really like this show. So informative and you’re gentle with the families. Teamwork makes the dream work!

I listen to this podcast every single day during work! Thankful for these two sharing their experiences and expertise in an informative and empathetic manner.

This is such a well produced podcast. I hesitate to listen because of the continual ad interruptions. I think it is over sponsored for the length of the show.

Great show.

Have been a faithful listener for a few years now. Content is great, both hosts have remarkable life experience to provide powerful insight.

I live an hour north of Rexburg, Idaho. You guys handled this case better than any other podcast I’ve heard that covered this. Ray Hermosillo is awesome and your interview with him was awesome! Thank you for your take!

I love everything about this podcast: the thoroughness of the research, the in-depth interviews, and the compassion both hosts show to each and every victim. Hands down my favorite podcast.

My most favorite podcast. I’ve been listening since day one. I look forward to every Tuesday when new episodes come out. I know people have made bad reviews about this podcast and it’s apparent misery loves company. This podcast is absolutely amazing and these guys are doing a great job!

These two people are pathologically addicted to making excuses for the police missteps. It’s saddens me, because in journalism, there has to be some objectivity. It’s simply the case that the police in some episodes have made mistakes, have hurt investigations and have mistreated victims’ families. These two professionals seem incapable of acknowledging that. Perhaps this kind of attitude contributes to the lack of accountability we sometimes see in poor or botched police work.

I’ve been listening for about a year now and am finally to the summer of 22! Want to watch them all. I am a huge fan, and have learned so much about crime, investigative work, and prosecution. Fantastic podcast, and the hosts are lovely and experts, make a great team. 💕

I’m hooked to this podcast!!! Definitely one the best, keep up the great work!!

I love this podcast! A great listen. Thx

This podcast has so many commercials. I’ve gotten to the point of hating the products that support this podcast and will never use any of them! Also, hosts are not interesting and state the obvious that any child would be able to ascertain. Have deleted from my podcast list.

Ashley will run this podcast into the ground with all her liberal crap like she did with Crime Junkies! Unsubscribing! 👎🏻

I just read on of the comments and after 2 years of listening I decided to good glee the female host and just wow. How this woman not gonna address her misconduct matters. I have no interest to list anymore cause it just seem too fraudulent. I should have known. Prosecutors are never up to any good. Should make an episode about how you got the name wrong in one of your cases and all the other stuff. Bye

You guys are amazing. The kind way you present the info just draws in the listener even when the story is breaking.

In your episode you specifically state his family DID NOT want their personal business out in public, then you make an episode including that information???? Was there no other case you could've covered instead?? Did you have any contact with the family to ensure they were okay with you capitalizing off of their pain that they wanted to keep private?

A sensitive yet informative procedural true crime podcast that is well researched and done with dignity and care for the victims and their families.

Used to love the insight of both the hosts…until I did more research on Anna-Sigga. She is not a reliable reporter, or a friend of the innocent. 0/10 recommend this podcast and any analysis by Anna-Sigga

I truly love this podcast, the views and perspectives, however, too long on commercials, too many commercials…. I understand that commercials are income, however, if the amount of commercials were limited, then this is on.y at best a 20-22 minute podcast once ALL the commercials are removed from the actual content of the podcast. You need to add more detailed information if the both of you keep the extremely excessive amount of commercials. Those long commercials are off-putting. Otherwise this is a great podcast.

I like that the podcast is actually about crime cases and not 30 mins of talking about themselves. They also give their perspectives from their expertise, which is interesting Update: still appreciate no unnecessary long banter, but my god Scott can really bother me when he says “familiar” as “ferrrrmillieerr” idk it’s just bothersome he does it with other words too. Lots of ads and a little iffy on Anna-Sigga and her history of not actually trying to pursue justice

It’s ok but there are far better true crime podcasts available. There are way way more commercials during the shows than most other shows it seems - and the episodes lack details..they make it sound like they are leaving out details to be more respectful but it comes across as lazy. I listen to this when I’ve run out of all my other choices.

I love the way this podcast breaks everything down and the explanations

I found the podcast only mildly interesting and listened only when I didn’t have anything else. Then I learned about Anna-Sigga’s cases being overturned. Look it up. I cannot support someone who lacks integrity and honesty when their job was to serve the public. Further more, you shouldn’t portray her as an expert in the field when her career is shadowed in wrongdoings. I will not continue to listen.

Love this podcast! I wanted to listen to true crime but never liked any until I found this one. I enjoy how the hosts bring guests who actually worked on the cases to bring more insight on said case. It can also bring a puzzle like atmosphere to the listeners, I personally peace things together along and it’s so much fun! And, I want to bring a moment of silence to the ones who pasts on. And I want to give a thanks to everyone who brought those justice and peace. Prost auf alle, cheers to all.

I just can’t listen to this podcast anymore after what I have learned about Anna-Sigga. I encourage you to look her up.

Google her Anna-Sigga Nicolazzi

I recently got into these true crime podcasts, and I can say this is an extraordinary start! They stories are so strong and compelling. Rather than seeing the bad, I can’t help but be amazed at these amazing people who have worked so hard to give these families closure. May God bless each and every one of those amazing people, and those who have passed on. These people 100% deserve the recognition. All I can say is, may the Holy Spirit be with everyone affected.

Started listening as an avid true crime follower. Then, I looked more into what Anna-Sicca Nicolazzi did (or should I say his) as a prosecutor and was appalled. She shouldn’t be hosting a podcast, she should be in jail. Disgusting.

Couldn’t understand the guy often interviewed. Volume goes up and down throughout which made for an unpleasant listening experience.

I was so moved by your show about Unique Harris. Her mother, Valencia, is a beautiful person. God bless her.

I’m pretty picky about my true crime podcast, this one is in the top three! They do an incredible job articulating the story and bringing stories to light that I’ve never heard of before! Thank you for sharing the story of Unique Harris. Too often, criminals take the spotlight. This episode showcases the great loss and suffering of losing a loved one, and how a mother’s love moves mountains.

Unique Harris. This piece was so well done but my heart broke for her family. Especially her mom and sons. I hope her mom can find Unique and have some peace.