I love Psych, but have never been much of one for podcasts or paid much attention to the lives of the people who make the shows I like. But Tim and Maggie, as well as their guests, have this way of just welcoming you into their Psych family. Genuine, heartfelt, and hilarious. Listen for the behind-the-scenes stories, and you can’t help but leave with a taste of the gratitude and compassion that is part of who they are.

Psych is one of my favorite shows of all time and I really wanted to love this podcast. I’ve listened to about 20 episodes and am calling it quits. I was hoping it would be more like the Office Ladies rewatch podcast where they give a lot of background info about behind the scenes and actors on the show. However, they speed through the recap and then move on and there is a lot of small talk that has nothing to do with the show. Hopefully it’ll get better for those that still listen.

Can you get Cary Elwes on the pod when you review the last Desperaux ep? “Lock, Stock, some Smoking Barrels, and Burton Guster’s Goblet of Fire”, if I’m not mistaken. Love that episode, love this podcast, and we NEED an interview with Tim on his five minutes of fame as Hephaestus in Percy Jackson! Love you guys!

Finding this podcast made my day. Psych has always been a comfort show of mine and getting to listen to the cast talk about the show has really brightened my days.

I enjoy the pod, but I find that Tim’s constant interruptions of the synopsis make it difficult (even a little stressful) to listen to. Maggie tends to kind of speed-read the synopsis, but I think it’s because she’s trying to get through it without being interrupted. Maybe if they actually rehearsed instead of winging it, they could decide where Tim wants/needs to interject and program those points in? I like the concept of the podcast, and I generally enjoy the content, but feel like even this one change would make a world of difference in the appeal of the show.

So disappointed in the quality that I can no longer listen to the podcast. The last episode for “We’d Like to Thank the Academy” missed so much detail of the episode. The episode is comic gold and no mention was made of the Police Academy homage, they missed a few Karate Kid references and the hosts blather on for the first 15 minutes about each other and dry January. They need to make a separate show for Tim and Maggie to talk to each other “YouTime” and stop wasting our Psych time. They are usually pretty terrible with guests on the show too, when they could actually interviewing them about their careers, their time on Psych. I am excited FOUR more Psych but this podcast, its million commercials and no actual Pysch content has me running away Gus screaming.

This podcast is pretty unbearable and I watch psych all seasons twice a year, just not a fun listen seems more like therapy for Tim, the bits arnt funny and so so repetitive, y’all are incredible actors and hilarious on the tv show but this podcast is no bueno.

I love psych and this pod just makes me love it more! Thank you for all you do Maggie and Tim! Just remember, don’t be a gooey chocolate chip cookie/ crevice in this arm/ rabid porcupine.🍍🍍🍍🍍

I honestly haven’t listened in a while because they don’t really give any info on the episodes or show. They just describe what’s happening in each scene, and they fly through that. But what i noticed while listening to season 5, episode 9…is that I can barely hear Maggie. It sounds like her mic is either off, or she’s sitting across the room from it. I don’t know if this is a one-off or if this is their new format when recording the podcast. Hopefully it’s just a fluke.

I love this podcast and LOVE psych (have seen the whole series over 15 times) but I wish the rewatch could come back! They are losing listeners and losing me. I’ll start listening again when the rewatch is back! Plus they already have other podcasts where they talk about other stuff, so if I wanted to hear that I’d just go listen there

Good until stopped doing the rewatch wished it was cleaner loved the show they love the past

Rarely does a really special and magical show come together so perfectly and impact our lives like Psych has. Psych began the year my husband and I got married and carried us through our first 7 yrs of marriage and the birth of all 3 of our children! Almost 10 yrs and 3 psych movies later, my youngest is now 8, and she and I watch psych every night together! It is our comfort show and every character on the show feels like family to us. We were so excited about the podcast bc of how much we have grown to LOVE these actors. Getting to spend as many moments with them as possible is a true gift. Thank you Maggie and Tim for continuing to spend time with us and keeping Psych alive!! ❤️

My Kids grew up with Psych and it’s constantly playing! also My late Aunt loved going to the tiki room in Disney Land and would always tell me about the talking pineapple named phillipe! i was laughing/crying listening to Steve Franks talk about that! Pretty positive she was there when he was!

This rewatch pod has been excellent and Tim & Maggie have great rapport :) that said, it’s been disappointing that there hasn’t been a “normal” episode in a while - even as a result of the SAG AFTRA strike, there should still be a weekly pod and it’s a disservice to the PSYCH fans, your advertisers, and of corse this podcast. It’s sad cause something similar happened to the Fake Doctors, Real Friends pod… politics just took over and it killed an excellent rewatch pod of one of the all time great shows! Let us know when the rewatch pod is back, we all have to go to work no matter what’s going on in the world so i expect the same from celebs, and the top 1% 🤷🏼‍♀️ thanks!

We are rewatching this show for the 4th or so time and I was reflecting on how amazing the soundtrack for this show is. While I was searching the app I use for music to see if someone has made a playlist for this show I stumbled upon this podcast. I’m so excited to listen! This has been a favorite show of mine for years!!

This my favorite show of all time. Psych is my go to if I need a laugh out loud day. I love Psych so much. I have watched it over and over since it came on peacock TV. Could you please bring it back I miss Sean and Gus. They are the funniest duo ever on any TV show. The rest of the cast make up the greatest ensemble group of funny characters ever to be assembled. This is the only show ever made that I just feel happy after watching it. Get Psych 4 started asap ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

Psych is my favorite show ever and I love it. I was able to finish the whole series for the 5th time and it still holds up so well🍍🍍and a little bit of bacon 🥓

🍍 It’s the best

Love this pod. Makes me feel like the show never ended. Thanks for all the hard work Maggie and Tim!!

Talk about the show, no body will listen

Psych has been my comfort show for years now! It’s so great to hear from Maggie and Tim and their perspective on everything. I’m learning so much more about the show I know so so well.

Psych is absolutely one of my favorite shows and this podcast with Maggie and Tim recreate every hilarious minute - bonus materials of the podcast include behind the scenes stories ! A must listen for any true Psych fan.

I started rewatch Psyhc recently and we do what we always do. Go to google and research “where are they now?” Boom! I find out that there is a rewatch podcast for our favorite detective. I’ve listened to a handful of the most recent episodes and love hearing our favorite detectives share their stories and memories of the episode. I am looking forward the season 5 episode 13 rewatch. Probably my favorite episode of all time with so many moving parts! Thank you Maggie and Tim!!

Tim and Maggie are hilarious and do a great podcast, keep up the good work!

Only on episode 3, but I can tell this is my new obsession. My husband and I have been watching Psych since it came out and we watch it everyday. EVERY. DAY. We finished? Oh, let’s watch it again. And I will do the same thing with these episodes🤣

What a treat to listen to this! So glad they promoted it on Ryan Bailey or else I’d never know about it!

This podcast does not make me want to weep and then die. And if you don’t like the podcast, don’t listen to it. It’s that’s simple. Some people are just whiny.

The duo’s chemistry and friendship is what makes this podcast. HOWEVER, the ads are absolutely terrible. Often times there’s 3+ ads back to back to back and it can happen multiples throughout the episode. Ad breaks should not be multiple minutes long. It’s so annoying having to hit the +30 second fast-forward almost ten times each ad break just to get back to the podcast.

“Hi Tim!” “Hi Maggie!” I love how much these two obviously enjoy each other. All the love between the whole cast for each other and the show is so lovely and pure - that’s what makes this podcast for me. I’m a big fan of rewatch podcasts, but this one is special just because the relationships make me smile. I love all the behind the scenes talk and the fun stories as well. Great job, I highly recommend. 😁

Aaaaahhhhhhh!!!🍍🍍🍍🍍🍍🍍🍍🍍🍍🍍🚙🚙🚙🚙🚙🚙🚙🚙🚙🚙🚙🚙🚙🚙🚙🚙

I love this podcast!! 100% love it!! 🍍🍍🍍🍍 I love Timothy and Maggie as hosts. I will say, they are definitely finding their groove more as the show goes on… but I feel that was true with the show as well. No “bad” episodes by any means…. it just got better and better as time went on. The guests are amazing! I especially love when Steve comes in, because he drops so many behind the scenes stories, details, and all kinds of “inside” info. My favorite episode so far was actually “Tuesday the 17th.” I learned SO much from that episode… it was just full of all kinds of facts and stories from James. It was great! Keep up the good work!! We love it!!!!! 🍍🍍🍍🍍 🚙🚙🚙🚙

Love the podcast but I’d like them to slow it down and also celebrate and speak to the incredibly funny lines in the show that they gloss right over. Spend more time on the backstories, locations, how it was shot, what was improvised etc. keep it up!

I think I’ve rewatched the entire show probably 20 times 😅😅 One of those feel good shows to keep on in the background, was sad to see it end, but between the movies and now the podcast it’s great to see y’all sticking around! Love the behind the scenes stories, great work guys! Glad Tim is doing much better

I watch Psych at least 5 times a week still. I love the show and love this podcast almost as much. Thursday is a highlight of the week because of Jules and Lassie!

I go back and forth on how much I like this podcast. I 💚 Psych, I 💚 Maggie & Tim…the pod is getting better. I miss that they don’t point out some of the funnier moments and jokes in some episodes…but overall it’s good and getting better. It’s also great to hear Tim every week. Tim, you sound great!

As a big fan of Psych, this podcast is very difficult to listen to. Rather than discussing the themes, production and even personal experience of making Psych, the hosts spend at least 50% of the podcast in a disorganized mess constantly interrupting one another with inside jokes revolving around their personal friendship, repeating things the other has just said to emphasize how funny they think it was and catch phrases that could possibly land if not so obviously forced. The guests however, add much needed energy and insight to what would otherwise just be two people making small talk.

Omg i love the show sooooo much! You guys are amazing. I have watched every episode about 10 times! I just finished rewatching the series AGAIN!!! Keep it up guys.

Love that this podcast continues the psych legacy. Only “problem” is that I rewatch psych (including all movies) and get ahead of this podcast! I’m already on season 6 for the third time since starting this podcast lol. So good to feel the chemistry from everyone involved in this show and in real life.

Thanks Maggie and Tim for this weekly gift, including such cherished guests. Its so hard to wait for each episode! I squirrel them away like acorns, waiting for the perfect time to settle in and enjoy.

Episode Eight was my favorite so far! Liked that there was more about the episode. Loving the podcast! The episode with jay chandrasekhar was GREAT. He would note the jokes in each scene and tell the story behind them. I think Devon’s summaries are great but wish there was more detail for each scheme and the dialogue. The jokes are what make the show!

love all you guys🍍 thanks for doing this. you guys got a good flow going

I’m a huge fan of Psych. This rewatch would be my 4th go around. After listening to the Scrubs and Parks & Rec rewatch podcast, I had very high hopes. The first few episodes were great with the principle casts. But the running jokes of muuuurrrrder and pointing out pepto pink, I’m over it. We get it, you love each other and I love that friendship but one episode was mostly them catching up and very little show.

I feel so connected to this podcast bc I’m on my 4th rewatching of Psych LOL. This is the best show!! It’s a must!! It will make you laugh anytime, anyday! 💖

Need more Dule Hill and James Roday Rodriguez.

Love this show so much and all of the psych love. How do I send them fan question?

I love Maggie and Tim together and have enjoyed all the guests they’ve had on. My only constructive criticism would be that it would be nice if they tried to do some research on the viewer questions before answering. Maybe they could contact a crew member, producer or writer and dig in a little on where things were filmed, etc. I think I’m spoiled with the Office Ladies podcast because they do serious research and tell you where and how things were filmed, etc. Also it feels like Maggie is reading the synopsis for the first time, maybe read through it ahead of time so it goes a little more smoothly. Thanks for a fun podcast!

I'm enjoying this rewatch with you two. Can't beat a show with fun clever writing!

While I think Maggie and Tim are absolutely adorable and their friendship is really sweet to hear, this podcast is sadly not a “rewatch” podcast. They talk very little about the episodes and behind the scenes things you don’t see on the show. They also repeat themselves A LOT. Tim tells the same story about his testing audition at least 3 times in the first 3 episodes and Maggie makes the same comments on her characters pantsuit outfits even more. I had such high hopes for this podcast because the tv show is so amazing. Unfortunately this missed the mark for me. They need more tidbits, behind the scenes info and more talking about the show itself.

These are the best! And ones with Steve Franks can’t get enough.

Not impressed.