I used to love the Choose Your Own Adventure books and this podcast just brings back all that nostalgia! I enjoy the vast difference in the choice making between the hosts!

Abby is funnier than your mom and even that one uncle.

What a delight! Hosts Peter and Abby combine silly hijinks with serious, thoughtful insights into each particular book and the series overall. It’s a blast reliving my youth with these two.

Hi, I’m [name redacted] and I’m [sort of] a librarian. I read as many of these books as I could find when I was a kid and it’s fun and nostalgic to revisit them. I was drawn to the weird, out of left field sci-fi and fantasy elements, and to the low-key horrific deaths these books would suddenly throw at you. I always kept my finger between the pages of the last fork in the road, in case I made the wrong choice. Love the gentle, goofy, midwestern vibe in my ear when I’m at work or commuting.

Always a blast and Abby is so funny!! Favorite episode is maybe Hyperspace but they’re all good!!

A truly delightful show! Never fails to make me smile and laugh!

My new favorite show! This really takes me back. Usually pretty funny and they do a good job discussing the books.

This feels like voting for ourselves for prom court, but King us, baby! I love me & Peter's podcast and recommend it to anyone who has ever read a CYOA book & wants a lil teehee. We appreciate you, readers & listeners!! <3

Library kids, unite! I spent way too much time reading and rereading all the Choose Your Own Adventure books as a kid, and librarians Peter and Abby are the perfect guides to help me relive all the wackiness that happened in them. If you choose to have a great time hanging with your new podcast friends, press play. If not, your story ends here. (But press play!)

Love this entertaining podcast that takes you back to your childhood. Bonus points - listening to Peter and Abby laugh through the whole thing makes me so happy!

5 stars and 5 warm hugs for Abby and Peter! Whether it’s Abby’s amazing references (like Dan Quail) or Peter’s play it safe mentality, this podcast is amazing!

If this podcast is great. Go to page 32 If this podcast is funny. Go to page 53

Very fun concept

Abby is soooooo funny! Love this show!

I read these books as a kid and never thought twice about how completely crazy they were—but Peter and Abby point out all the weirdness, inconsistencies, and just plain oddities of these adventures in a hilarious way. After listening to these two I find myself seriously wondering about my childhood reading preferences.

When will you be covering the Lone Wolf series? Inquiring minds want to know.

I love this show!! Abby and Peter work really well together.